I recently read an article about the Vatican reprimanding American nuns for not focusing enough on homosexuality and abortion in America. The article cites the Vatican as saying American nuns are “too focused on social justice and not enough on opposing abortion, euthanasia and same-sex marriage.”
Let me begin by saying this article isn’t to slander the Catholic church, but rather to share an issue I see in religious circles, especially Christian (Protestant and Catholic). The political/social agenda we carry and expect our religious institutions to carry determines whether we see them as effective or not. This is hardly new, I know, but it is interesting to watch it play out. Churches and religious groups criticize one another and even themselves in this case for not carrying out the agenda mandated by the leaders. The Christian right is another example of this. What’s seen as “right” can shift over time (think the acceptance of Blacks as people, women’s rights, etc). What’s even more interesting to me is the argument that the focus on social justice is, well, not wrong-rather not the most important “right” issue to fight right now. Who decides what’s the righter right issue? In my opinion it seems to be entirely driven by the media and social forces. Of course there was a concerted effort by certain groups within religious institutions to bring about change like with the Civil Rights movement, but this hardly happened within the context of a completely or even half-way unified religious community. I see it more so as people who were like-minded on the outcome they desired, were driven by religious fervor and brought their vision to pass.
Were the people who didn’t want to fight for Civil Rights as issue number one wrong? No, not at all. I take strong issue with the religious Right on the grounds that they’ve decided which issues they, and in their amazingly arrogant opinion, God cares about the most and imply that those who disagree are not aligned with God. I think people can operate based on whatever motivating factors they want and have any issue they care for be the most important to them. I can’t agree with anyone who thinks that their pet issue reigns supreme. Let them make the change they see as most important and let others who feel whatever is most important do the same on their pet issue. Maybe my “right” fight is wrong to you because your “right” fight is different than mine. That doesn’t mean the fight I’m fighting is overall wrong just because it isn’t your top priority. That’s the argument I reject outright. Of course, when the two sides oppose each other on Biblical grounds as if God is schizophrenic, that creates whole other host of issues but that’s for another post.
Conversations at Work
Discussion with co-worker while surfing Amazon: There are a ton of different Cheerios: Dulce de Leche Cheerios, Peanut Butter Cheerios, Chocolate Cheerios. General Mills has really been slutting those Cheerios out!
Leave a comment
March 27, 2012 · 9:29 pm